Girls in Capes

Women, men & minorities in geek culture and pop culture

Lessons from Childhood: The Lion King and Poverty

Like many a 90’s child, The Lion King was one of my very favorite movies growing up. Timon and Pumbaa were funny, I couldn’t resist crying a little when Mufasa died, and it was tons of fun bouncing around on my couch with my little sister while singing “I Just Can’t Wait to Be King” in obnoxious little-kid voices.

But there was something that always bothered me a little about The Lion King that I never quite understood until I got older: people hated the hyenas. Sure, they weren’t exactly nice to Simba – actually, they were terrifying – but I always felt bad for them, and I never exactly knew why.

Hyenas

It wasn’t until I read this article from Cracked.com when I realized exactly what it was about Shenzi, Banzai, and Ed that gave me the shivers as a child. In the movie, it’s made clear that the hyenas are “slobbery, mangy, stupid poachers” and eventually help Scar take over the Pridelands. How awful, amirite? Why would they ever do something to help the bad guy?

Except that, as the writer points out,

They want something to eat. That’s their problem, and it’s only a problem because Mufasa banished them from the Pride Land and forced them to live in an elephant graveyard, which is no place to raise a child, hyena or otherwise.

That got the gears working. Then I thought about something I’d discussed with a friend a few years ago, a friend who was utterly convinced The Lion King was racist. Her reasoning? Apart from the fact that Shenzi is voiced by (black) Whoopi Goldberg and Banzai is voiced by (Mexican) Cheech Marin, my friend was upset by the overall depiction of the hyenas – dirty, uneducated, living in the Pridelands equivalent of the ghetto, and stereotypically criminal.  It was easy to see how she could reach such a conclusion.

However, the article and my friend’s conclusion started coming together when I recalled a lecture I attended in high school about depictions of race in Disney’s Dumbo. While the general buzz about Dumbo is that it’s clearly racist, the presenter, a professor of English at the nearby university, interpreted the movie’s imagery as well as other events at the time it was made to determine that the film is actually about a mixed-race child, with Dumbo’s Indian elephant mother representing a white woman and his African elephant father – where he got his large ears – representing a black man, resulting in the film chronicling the plight and exploitation of a mixed-race child.

Not all stereotypical depictions of race are a display of the creators’ racism. Sometimes stereotypical depictions of race serve to help the creators call out the racism of others.

lionking-disneyscreencaps.com-3360

So let us begin again and start looking at the hyenas through this lens.

First, there’s the problem of hyena “villainy” in The Lion King. The very first time we see the hyenas, they’re trying to eat Simba and Nala – evil and sinister, right? Except we’ve established that the hyenas are starving and motivated primarily by food. That is exactly how Scar manages to make them his minions: he provides them food – he gives them ONE SINGLE ZEBRA LEG before the “Be Prepared” sequence – despite his obvious disdain for their intelligence and overall quality of life. In fact, look at what the hyenas are excited about when Scar talks about killing Mufasa and Simba, and especially after he tells them “Stick with me, and you’ll never go hungry again”:

In case you missed it, let me point out just what the hyenas are saying in the background during the eerie marching scene:

Ooh – ooh la la la!
We’ll have food!
Lots of food!
We repeat
Endless meat

If we continue envisioning the hyenas as a commentary on race, it’s clear that the hyenas’ role in “Be Prepared” is an example of just what motivates poor minorities to reject authority figures and, to some extent, become involved in criminal activity.

The hyenas are forced to live in a deteriorating environment by a ruling class that repeatedly describes them as having overall lower intelligence and worth. They only join Scar because he promises to meet their basic needs – specifically food, which can stand in for any basic need such as shelter, protection, or anything else – even though Shenzi’s expression after Scar grabs her face and her in “Be Prepared” makes it obvious she dislikes how Scar treats them. They even turn on Scar after hearing him tell Simba they’re the lions’ enemies, disproving his apparent idea they’re too stupid to understand when someone’s insulting them.

The parallels between the hyenas and groups living in poverty create a striking image of the disparity between the rich and poor in society, especially when examining the qualities and characteristics of each named hyena as portrayed by its actor: Shenzi seems to be a young black woman, Banzai can be interpreted as a Latino immigrant, and Ed likely depicts a mentally ill or mentally disabled individual.

While anyone could read the surface ripples to decide minorities are depicted as inherently evil or sinister, I truly believe in a deeper interpretation: these “children’s stories” show us that while we as a society continue to marginalize minority groups and ignore their essential needs, we can only expect them to turn to the first person who will provide them with the basic needs – food, shelter, even friendship and acceptance – regardless of the consequences.

Feliza Casano is the founder and editor in chief of Girls in Capes and writes for all sections of the web magazine. She, too, is often motivated by food.

Advertisements

About Feliza

Feliza Casano is a writer and editor with a love of speculative fiction, graphic novels, and good books. She writes and edits at Girls in Capes (GirlsinCapes.com) and contributes to other websites on science fiction and fantasy topics.

5 comments on “Lessons from Childhood: The Lion King and Poverty

  1. Reblogged this on Big Blue Dot Y'all and commented:
    Think on this. Ask the hard questions.

  2. Pingback: Lessons from Childhood: The Lion King and Poverty | julie chicklitasaurus

  3. rayoflight7777
    May 10, 2013

    Amazing when you look at it this way how easily we can be drawn into fighting ourselves and brainwashed into supporting those who exploit us.

    I would like to point out that the strongest defense against this kind of manipulation (like what Hitler did, clearly referenced in this sequence) is a realization of our spiritual Oneness. No one can be demonized if we don’t believe in demons. As Neale Donald Walsch said, speaking as God, “I have sent you only angels.”

    Having said that, let us do our best not to demonize the exploiters, also, and I need to follow this advice myself. They, I believe, are simply misled.

    • Feliza C.
      May 12, 2013

      I think that’s a great point – if you’ve ever seen The Lion King 2, which was a direct-to-video sequel, they actually address that directly in the song “We Are One,” and the idea that all lions are “one” is a major theme.

  4. Pingback: Segregation and Discrimination Is Alive and Well against the Roma in Slovakia | Eunoic

Join the Conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on May 10, 2013 by in TV & Film and tagged , , , , , , .

The Team

Enter your email address to join The Team and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 656 other followers

Team Tweets

%d bloggers like this: